1. What is your main takeaway from Sontag’s essay?
We cannot truly understand or imagine how terrifying wars are. Photographers know that, so they take pictures of people's suffering, making it into an art that aims at shocking people. The media use these pictures to justify wars or calling for revenge, but sometimes these cruel pictures make people indifferent, not empathetic. To stop the war, showing cruel images is not enough. Compassion needs to be translated into action.
2. Give at least two smaller takeaways from the essay. Things that you found
to be of particular interest. This can include things that surprised you or provoked
some thoughts.
1) It is a shame and shock to look at pictures of people suffering in war. The author is saying that maybe only people who can alleviate the pain have the right to look at those images. That gives me an excuse of avoiding looking at these cruel images. I have to admit that I feel empathetic and terrified at the same time when looking at these images. I just want to cry when even thinking of their sufferings.
2) Media like to use shocking and dramatic images as a source of value, as a lost art. That reminds me of Beato who usually rearranged bodies before he took a picture. These pictures turn people into things that can be possessed, without any dignity.
3. Upload an image of pain/suffering to your blog and discuss it. You can be
straightforward about this, or you can take a well-known image that you may
look at differently after reading Sontag.
I cannot look at any cruel pictures. This picture is my limit. Like many people, I was empathetic when seeing a little kid lying dead on beach, wondering what happened to him. It is because of wars that people become refugees and have to flee their country. There have been heated debates about how to deal with these refugees, but few questions are asked about how to stop wars. Images like this seem unreal, and people cannot imagine other people's pain by simply looking at these cruel images. But at least compassion is part of the human being and also the seed for action.